Best Electric Fireplace Insert for Existing Fireplaces

FireplaceIQ is reader supported. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a commission. It never changes what you pay. Details in our affiliate disclosure.

The best electric fireplace insert for most existing fireplaces is the PuraFlame Western: the most convincing flame under $400, a resistance heater that genuinely warms a mid-size room, and sizes that fit standard masonry openings. Spend more for the Dimplex Revillusion if realism is the whole mission, less for the Dimplex DFI2310 if the fireplace is small. Before any of that, measure your opening, because fit, not features, is where insert purchases go wrong.

• Best overall: PuraFlame Western, about $390 for the 26 inch when we checked in July 2026
• Best flame realism: Dimplex Revillusion 25 inch
• Best budget: Dimplex DFI2310, 23 inch
• Best modern linear look: Touchstone Sideline 45 inch

Measure your fireplace before reading reviews

Five numbers: opening height, width at the front, width at the back (masonry tapers), depth, and hearth depth in front. The height measurement disqualifies more inserts than any other, and it was the number one install pain in the hundreds of Amazon and Home Depot reviews we mined this July. One reviewer’s fix, shimming the insert level with scrap plywood, works, but ordering the right size works better.

Match the insert’s listed firebox dimensions against your smallest measurements, and leave an inch of breathing room around the intake vents. If your opening is unusual, tall and narrow, or very shallow, a wall of trim panels beats forcing a standard box.

Best overall: PuraFlame Western

The Western wins because it gets the one thing right that buyers return inserts over: the fire looks like fire. Three flame colors, adjustable brightness, resin logs with a crackle-free but convincing glow, and a 1,400 watt heater rated for about 400 square feet. It comes in 26, 30, and 33 inch widths, and the 26 was about $390 when we checked in July 2026.

The honest downsides from the review stream: the heater is real but modest, a 12 by 12 room warms nicely and a great room does not change temperature, and the blower is audible on high. Buyers who wanted silence and buyers who wanted furnace heat are the two unhappy groups; neither should buy any plug-in insert.

Best realism: Dimplex Revillusion

The Revillusion projects its flame onto a mirage screen behind physical logs instead of behind them, and the depth effect is the best in the category, this is the insert people walk up to and touch. The 25 inch model runs $600 to $700 at 2026 retail, roughly double the Western, for a flame maybe 30 percent better. Whether that trade makes sense is a personality question, not a spec question.

Downside beyond price: it is a plug-in 120V unit like the rest, so the heat is the same 5,000 BTU class as inserts a third its price. You are paying entirely for the picture.

Best budget: Dimplex DFI2310

A 23 inch insert that has been the default small-fireplace answer for a decade, around $250 in 2026. Single flame style, simple controls, reliable heater, and a footprint that fits the smaller masonry openings the bigger names skip. The flame is a generation older than the Western’s and looks it. For a den fireplace that needs to stop being a cold hole in the wall, it is the right amount of money.

Best linear look: Touchstone Sideline 45

If your fireplace opening is wide or you are rebuilding the surround anyway, the Sideline’s edge-to-edge ribbon of flame turns a traditional firebox modern. About $500 at July 2026 pricing for the 45 inch, with crystal or log media and multiple flame colors. Check depth carefully: Sidelines are designed for recessed wall mounting, and fireplace installs need the opening to swallow their full depth plus clearance.

What no insert on this page will do

Heat like the wood fire the fireplace was built for. Every plug-in insert caps at 1,500 watts, about 5,000 BTU, enough to make the fireplace room comfortable and nowhere near whole-home heat. The running cost guide covers the meter side: about 28 cents an hour on high at 2026 average rates, pennies on flame-only.

If you need real heat from that opening, the honest alternatives are a gas insert at 20,000+ BTU or a wood insert, both at several times the cost. The electric insert is the right call when the goals are looks, safety, a dead or unlined flue, and a room that needs help, not salvation.

Plug-in or hardwired?

Plug-in for nearly everyone: every pick above runs on a standard 120V outlet, and the only requirement is an outlet near the firebox that does not share a circuit with another heavy load. A few larger models offer 240V hardwiring that doubles heat output, worth it only if an electrician is already coming and heat is a priority. Reviewers who direct-wired into an existing fireplace outlet flagged the flexibility of models that support both, worth checking if your outlet situation is odd.

How we picked

We compared current spec sheets across the insert category, then read the review streams, hundreds of Amazon and Home Depot reviews mined July 10, 2026, for the failure patterns specs hide: flame realism disappointment, sizing surprises, blower noise, and remote failures. Nobody paid for placement and no manufacturer saw this page early. Prices are July 2026 checks and move around; treat them as anchors, not promises.

More electric guides live in the Electric Fireplaces hub, and renters should read the wall mount vs recessed comparison before committing to an insert at all.

Electric fireplace insert FAQ